Unjust Dismissal Under Canada Labour Code

Standard of Correctness

The standard of correctness, however, provides that there is only one correct answer. This standard may apply where one of the following submissions are made: There is an issue relating
Read More »

Deference

  The review of the adjudicative award is based on the standard of reasonableness. This is the presumption whenever a court reviews administrative decisions. In order for an administrative decision
Read More »

Standards of Judicial Review

Broadly speaking, remedial orders made in labour cases are allowed a “wide margin of appreciation”. Such issues “go to the very heart of the specialized expertise of labour adjudicators”. This
Read More »

Aggravated & Punitive Damages

There is no dispute that the adjudicator appointed to hold an Unjust Dismissal hearing has the authority to award aggravated and/or punitive damages. This was confirmed in by the Federal
Read More »

Remedy in Lieu of Reinstatement

Future Loss The question arises as to what compensation, if any, should be ordered where reinstatement has been denied. The Federal Court of Appeal in its 2023 decision noted that
Read More »

Legal Costs in Unjust Dismissal

The Federal Court of Appeal considered a judicial review application in which the employee had been awarded partial indemnity costs. She sought, on review, full indemnity costs. The Court of
Read More »

Remedy – Lost Income

  The principle of assessing such a loss is not based on wrongful dismissal concepts. This principle is firm. The purpose of the monetary remedy is, as in the case
Read More »

Reinstatement – Anecdotal

The principled review is discussed above. Review Both Sides The issue of reinstatement was reviewed by the Federal Court of Appeal in The employer had failed to renew the teaching
Read More »

Remedy of Reinstatement

  Remedies The broad purpose of the remedy is one intended to place the innocent party into the position of “not suffering an employment related disadvantage as a result of
Read More »