Why terminate while a return to work remains possible?
In Seth v K-Bro Linen Systems Inc., 2026 ABKB 790, the employer moved a senior production manager to unpaid medical leave after a back injury prevented him from performing the essential duties of his job. It asked him to apply for long-term disability benefits and kept his position open for him to return when medically fit. The Alberta Court of King’s Bench held that both steps were reasonable and justified in the circumstances. K-Bro did not argue frustration. Its position was that the employment relationship continued during the leave. Seth, paras. 3–4 and 195–200
A temporary accommodation can run its course
Sunil Seth had worked for K-Bro for nearly 42 years. After his injury, K-Bro let him work from home on full salary. He could perform administrative tasks and monitor the plant’s cameras. Another manager had to supervise the production floor, respond to problems as they arose and work additional hours. The judge found that these on-site responsibilities were essential to Seth’s job. Continuing the remote arrangement indefinitely would effectively have turned his position into a different job, with someone else carrying out its core functions. Seth, paras. 141–163
K-Bro continued Seth’s full salary for about three months after the remote arrangement ended. By April, his expected return date had shifted twice. The medical information still indicated that he could not attend the plant, and his surgeon had given no return date. The judge also found that none of the medical notes recommended working from home. The initial remote arrangement was reasonable when the parties expected a relatively short absence. The experience of actually trying it, together with the updated medical information, justified revisiting it. Seth, paras. 144–158, 164–174 and 181–185
Accommodation in a common-law constructive dismissal action
At para. 140, the judge explained that accommodation principles informed the common-law question of whether K-Bro was justified in withholding duties. The Supreme Court’s decision in Potter, which concerned an administrative suspension, supplied the framework for asking whether withholding work was reasonable and justified in the circumstances. Hydro-Québec informed the accommodation inquiry. Employers may have to modify duties or working conditions to enable an employee to work. On the evidence in Seth, continuing remote work would have required stripping the position of its essential functions. Potter v New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10, paras. 85–86 · Hydro-Québec, 2008 SCC 43, paras. 16–17 · Seth, paras. 138–140 and 159–163
Two appellate decisions cited by the judge provide the closest common-law comparisons.
- In McAlpine, a manager returning from disability leave could perform heavily modified duties from home. The B.C. Court of Appeal rejected her constructive dismissal claim. It held that accommodation did not create a contractual obligation to delete managerial duties that were significant in both time and responsibility. McAlpine v Econotech Services Ltd., 2004 BCCA 111, paras. 27–28
- In Irvine, the employer told a general manager with deteriorating eyesight that he could return when he recovered, then filled his position within two weeks. The Manitoba Court of Appeal found constructive dismissal. K-Bro’s conduct supported its assurance that Seth could return. It tried remote work, relied on medical information and kept the position open. It reorganized its staffing only after Seth sued. Irvine v Gauthier (Jim) Chevrolet Oldsmobile Cadillac Ltd., 2013 MBCA 93, para. 63 · Seth, paras. 164–166
Why decline to apply for LTD?
The reasons leave Seth’s motive unclear. Under the plan, the initial question was whether he could perform the essential duties of his own occupation. He could have disclosed the work he was still capable of doing and let Manulife assess his eligibility. K-Bro kept him on leave after he declined to apply, and its evidence was that he could return to his full job and pay once fit even if the insurer denied benefits. Applying offered a chance to replace lost income while his job remained open. The judge went further and found that, on these facts, applying was part of Seth’s obligation to participate in the accommodation process. Seth, paras. 175–200
Keeping the job open, with or without LTD
The traditional frustration inquiry asks whether the employee’s incapacity has made continued performance of the contract impossible in the relevant sense. K-Bro had a more immediate question. What should it do while Seth was unable to perform the essential duties and a return remained possible? It granted medical leave and kept the job open. The court found that course reasonable and dismissed the constructive dismissal claim. It then applied established repudiation principles to find that, in the circumstances, Seth resigned by filing his action. Seth, paras. 167–174, 195–200 and 212–220
The same course may be preferable even where the employer has no LTD plan. If the medical evidence shows that the employee cannot presently perform the essential duties with reasonable accommodation, and a return remains a realistic possibility, why terminate? Grant medical leave, confirm in writing that the job remains open, and reassess work capacity and accommodation as the medical information changes. Whether the leave is paid depends on the applicable contract, statute or policy. The absence of an LTD plan affects the employee’s access to income replacement. The decision to keep the job open turns on the prospects for a return and what accommodation is reasonably available.